Identified by CAMRA as having a nationally important historic pub interior, the Three Horseshoes is nicknamed 'Polly's' after a former landlady, Polly Burton. The pub was originally two separate buildings but now has two rooms. To the left is a long bar with a quarry-tiled floor and open fires, wooden bench seating and pre-war fittings; to the right is a similarly furnished small snug.
The pub has been renovated and refurbished, without any loss of historic charm or interest, and remains an unspoiled gem. Bryan and Niamh offer a very friendly welcome to locals and visitors alike. The outside seating area has been modernised and upgraded, and is now a sun-trap when the weather is cooperative. The old cash drawer has now been replaced by an electronic till.
Crusty cobs are available. First Wednesday of the month: Jacket potatoes with a variety of fillings. On Saturdays and Sundays, a weekly special is available.
Historic Interest
On National Inventory.
Three star - A pub interior of outstanding national historic importance
Listed status: II
A completely unspoilt local, in a former coal-mining village, sympathetically refurbished by the tenant who took over in 2022.
The pub is nicknamed ‘Polly Burton’s’ after the former landlady’s grandmother who started the business well over a century ago. The 1882 date on the front records when it was created from four cottages. A small entrance lobby, complete with off-sales hatch, leads into the public bar on the left. All-over quarry-tiled flooring and extensive bench seating straddle the two former cottage rooms. The servery fittings and both fireplaces are original and the only change seems to be the boxing-in of the seating in the late 20th century. Right of the lobby, a small snug has a bare wooden floor, Victorian fireplace and basic bench seating; service is from a hatch to the back of the bar servery. If this room is closed a polite request at the bar will allow entry.
This completely unspoilt local in a former coal-mining village was a beerhouse in the mid-19th century. Formerly in the hands of the Burton/Callaghan family since 1909 and was nicknamed 'Polly's', after the former landlady's grandmother. The present tenant took over in June 2022 and has carried out a very sympathetic refurbishment. The 1882 date on the frontage probably may indicate alterations that turned it into the present structure. In the tiny inner lobby, which is more like a vestibule with part-glazed partition walls, the off-sales hatch with its diminutive sash windows is still in use today (although only occasionally). The public bar is through the latch door to the left which has a '1' on the inside - a requirement of licensing magistrates in the past to number pub rooms. The public bar has been this size since the building was converted to pub use as the red quarry-tiled floor and the extensive bench seating straddle 'the join' of two rooms in the former cottages. Original fittings include the low bar counter, bar-back shelves and wood surround fireplaces at the front left and rear right with rows of glazed bricks. Note the baffle at the end of the seating near the exit door to outside toilets. The only change seems to be the boxing-in of the seating in the later 20th century towards the rear. The only modern item is the piano which is played for the occasional sing-song. To the right of the lobby is the tiny snug with a bare wooden floor, another Victorian fireplace with rows of tiles down each side and basic bench seating. Service is from a hatch to the back of the bar servery. There are three tables with Formica tops well worn from the regular playing of dominoes on them. This room is now used mainly for special occasions but a polite request at the bar will allow a viewing. Outside gents' and ladies' toilets.
This Pub serves 1 changing beer and 2 regular beers.
Three Horseshoes, Whitwick
Source: National